First amendment
Washington Supreme Court
Right to Counsel – A defendant is not completely denied counsel when his attorney declines to argue the defendant’s motion to withdraw his guilty plea at the sentencing hearing if: defense counsel remains present, defense counsel does not withdraw, is not conflicted, does not undermine the defendant’s position, and the defendant is allowed to make the argument. An allegation of ineffective assistance of counsel alone does not create a conflict or require substitution of counsel. Here, the defendant was not completely denied counsel and was, therefore, not entitled to automatic reversal. State v. Korsakas, No. 104065-2 (May 21, 2026)
Interfering with Reporting Domestic Violence – The Interfering with Reporting DV statute defines a single crime and is not an alternative means crime. RCW 9A.36.150. The alleged alternative acts in the statute do not criminalize the defendant’s conduct. Rather, they concern the acts of victims and witnesses and do not criminalize those acts. This decision resolves a split by affirming Division Three, and overturning Division One’s opinion in Nonog. State v. Buck, No. 104170-5 (May 14, 2026)
Division I
Appearance of Fairness Doctrine – A judicial proceeding satisfies the appearance of fairness doctrine if a reasonably prudent and disinterested person would conclude that all parties received a fair, impartial, and neutral hearing. Here, the jury administrator informed the judge, during a bench trial, that she overheard someone from a victim support organization tell one of the child victims to “remember this signal” and then saw her make a motion with her hand, before entering the courtroom. The trial judge’s failure to bring this to the parties’ attention before the trial ended, combined with the trial judge’s statement that he doubted that members of the victim support organization would engage in witness signaling, could cause a reasonable person to suspect judicial bias, and to believe that the defendant was denied a fair trial. Thus, the defendant is entitled to a new trial under the appearance of fairness doctrine. State v. Lester, No. 88956-7-I (May 18, 2026)
Division II
Sentencing – Monschke’s holding that mandatory life without parole is unconstitutional as applied to 18- to 20-year-old defendants does not apply to a defendant who was 22 years old when he committed the murders. The sentencing court was not required to consider the mitigating qualities of youth. State v. Pate, No. 60300-4-II (May 12, 2026, Unpublished)
First Amendment – A government agency may place reasonable viewpoint neutral, time place and manner restrictions on speech in a nonpublic forum. In addition, speech made with the intent to facilitate criminal conduct is unprotected speech. Here, the plaintiff had a history of sending vulgar offensive emails to agency staff. The agency responded by telling the plaintiff that he could only send emails to a single agency email address, unless he signed a “behavioral contract” (which he did not sign). The plaintiff violated the restriction. The agency again told the plaintiff to stop sending derogatory, harassing, or threatening emails, citing RCW 9A.76.180 (Intimidating a public servant). The plaintiff sued alleging a First Amendment violation. The trial court correctly dismissed the case. The plaintiff’s speech was not protected because it violated the agency’s reasonable restriction. Iceberg v. Tigerson, No. 60840-5-II (May 12, 2026, Unpublished)
Division III:
First amendment – The First Amendment allows a substantial amount of speech regulation within the physician-patient relationship but does not allow similar regulation of the doctor’s speech on the doctor’s public blog without a compelling interest. Here, the state did not violate the doctor’s First Amendment rights when it disciplined him for telling his patients to take Ivermectin and nebulized hydrogen peroxide for COVID-19. But the state violated the doctor’s First Amendment rights when it disciplined him for making similar statements on his public blog, because the state did not have a compelling interest in preventing the speech, and had not shown harm resulting from the Doctor’s blog posts. Wilkinson v. Washington Medical Commission, No. 40061-1-III (Sept. 16, 2025).