Discovery

WEEKLY ROUNDUP FOR THE WEEK OF JANUARY 27, 2025

Division III:

Terry stops – An officer may conduct a warrantless safety sweep of an unoccupied vehicle pursuant to a Terry stop.  Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032, 103 S. Ct. 3469 (1983) was not overruled by Arizona v. Gant, 556 U.S. 332, 129 S. Ct. 1710 (2009).  State v. Howard, No. 39665-7-III (January 28, 2025).

Insanity acquittees – A person found not guilty by reason of insanity and committed to a state hospital is entitled to credit for time served against the maximum term of commitment only for the time spent detained pretrial for evaluation or treatment pursuant to Chapter 10.77 RCW.  State v. Phillips, No. 39857-9-III (January 30, 2025).

9th Circuit:

Relevance – Evidence of the value of the defendant’s illegal narcotics is relevant even when it is not an element of the offence because it tends to disprove unwitting possession.  United States v. Velasqez, No. 24-5359 (January 21, 2025).

Foreign case of interest:

Discovery – The party seeking production of smartphone data must 1) provide “some evidence” of the smartphone’s use by the person from whom the data is sought – relatively low burden but mere suspicion or speculation is insufficient to justify intruding into the privacy interests of an opposing party; 2) describe each item and category with reasonable particularity, which specifically applies to the subject matter of the information sought and the temporal scope of the request unless the contents are unknown or unknowable. Jennings v. Smiley, No. 24S-CT-186 (Ind., January 24, 2025)

(Editor’s note: Indiana Trial Rule 26(B) is identical to Washington’s CR 26(B). The case collects several relevant cases from outside jurisdictions.)

Topics