Blake
Washington Supreme Court
Blake Refunds – The invalidation of the simple drug possession statute in Blake does not entitle individuals to a refund of drug court participation fees. State v. Peterson, No. 104536-1 (Sep. 10, 2026)
U.S. Supreme Court:
Party presentation rule – Under the party-presentation rule the parties frame the issues for decision, and the court serves as neutral arbiter of matters the parties present. A court violates the party-presentation rule by granting relief on a claim that the defendant never asserted. In this case, the U.S. Supreme Court held that the Fourth Circuit “departed so drastically from the principle of party presentation as to constitute an abuse of discretion.” Clark v. Sweeney, No. 25-53 (Nov. 24, 2025).
Washington Supreme Court:
Recall Petitions – When a recall petition charges an elected official with violating the Open Public Meetings Act (OPMA), the petitioner must have knowledge of facts indicating an intent to violate the OPMA. Here, the record indicated that the commissioner attended an executive session where legal counsel was not present, and that therefore the attorney-client privilege exception to the OPMA did not apply. But the record failed to indicate that the petitioner had personal knowledge that the commissioner intended to violate the OPMA. Thus, the recall petition was legally insufficient. In Re Petition for Recall of Commissioner Lisa Olsen, No. 104087-3 (Dec. 4, 2025).
Blake – Individuals with invalidated convictions do not have a right to be reimbursed for community service work performed in lieu of LFOs under the Equal Protection Clause. The individuals alleging Equal Protection violations did not prove disparate treatment because the community service option was not limited to the poor. Further, equal protection claims require “significant state action” which the court found lacking because the community service was performed at nonprofit organizations and not for the State. State v. Danielson, No. 103627-2 (Dec. 11, 2025)
Division I:
Right to Appeal – Ordinarily, entry of a guilty plea that admits the sufficiency of the state’s evidence waives any subsequent challenge to that evidence. And ordinarily, a sentence within the standard range shall not be appealed. RCW 9.94A.585(1). But a defendant may reserve the right to appeal the denial of his motions to suppress evidence if the state agrees to it when the defendant enters his guilty plea (which the state did in this case). State v. Nielsen, No. 86402-5-I (Nov. 24, 2025, unpublished).
(Editor’s note: A better practice is for the parties agree to a stipulated facts bench trial following the denial of the defendant’s motions to suppress. Then the defendant can appeal the denial of his motions to suppress, and the appeals court will not have to struggle with the reservation of a right to appeal in a guilty plea statement that conflicts with the ordinary rules about what can be appealed.)
Competency – Where the evidence shows that DSHS made significant efforts to provide timely restoration services, but several structural barriers and resource limitations outside of its control left it unable to do so, a trial court abuses its discretion holding DSHS in contempt, as inability to comply is an affirmative defense to contempt. Courts may not impose sanctions for contempt based solely on a violation of the time requirements in RCW 10.77.605. RCW 10.77.605(9). However, courts may impose sanctions for contempt if the order that DSHS violated required DSHS to comply with the time requirements of due process (assuming DSHS is able to comply). State v. DSHS, No. 87697-0-I (Dec. 8, 2025).
Division II:
Evidence – A trial court does not abuse its discretion by allowing the state to refresh a witness’s recollection with an exhibit that the court excluded from evidence as a discovery sanction. A court has wide discretion to determine the sanction for a discovery violation and to determine whether something can be used to refresh a witness’ memory. State v. Newberry, No. 58893-5-II (Nov. 25, 2025, unpublished).
Division III:
Public Records Act (PRA) – A court may sanction a PRA plaintiff for failing to answer questions, or evading questions, during a deposition. An initial five-day response letter does not violate the PRA for failing to provide an estimated response time if the agency sent the letter during the COVID-19 pandemic when the governor paused the operation of RCW 42.56.520(1). An agency does not fail to produce responsive records if the requester asked for all emails that person A sent to the requester, and the agency withholds emails that person B sent to the requester using person A’s email account. The standard of review is de novo for reviewing a trial court’s decision to grant an injunction to protect an agency from harassing records requests from a prisoner, per RCW 42.56.565, if the trial court’s decision was based on a documentary record, not on live witness testimony. Here, the trial court erred in granting the injunction because the evidence of harassment was insufficient to support the injunction. Noyola v. Washington State DOC, No. 39698-3-III (Motion to Publish granted Dec. 9, 2025).
Foreign case of interest:
Takings – A county ordinance was enacted during the COVID-19 pandemic that prohibited all access to privately-owned beaches. County officers, to enforce the ordinance, entered the landowner’s property and excluded the landowners under threat of arrest. This was a “textbook physical taking” that entitled the plaintiffs to just compensation under U.S. Const. amend. V. Alford v. Walton County, No. 21-13999 (Nov. 17, 2025 11th Cir).
Weapons – A steak knife with a rounded tip and a 4 ½ inch blade is not a per se “weapon”. State v. Cortes, 374 Or. 461 (2025).
Washington Supreme Court:
Juvenile court warrants – Juvenile Courts may not issue warrants unless the “individual circumstances” of the violation pose a “serious threat to public safety.” JuCR 7.16. Threats solely to the juvenile’s own safety do not meet this requirement. JuCR 7.16 does not conflict with RCW 13.40.040(1)(a) because juvenile courts can, and must, comply with both – the two can be harmonized by requiring juvenile courts to comply with the “threat to public safety” requirement. However, if there was a conflict, the statute would yield to the rule in this case because the issuance of warrants is procedural, which falls in the Supreme Court’s inherent, constitutional, and statutory power. State v. A.M.W., No. 103006-1 (August 14, 2025).
(Editor’s note: Justice Madsen’s dissent contains a discussion of the Supreme Court’s authority to promulgate procedural rules that is worth reading.)
Firearm rights restoration – A petition to restore firearms rights may be filed in any superior court in Washington and any Superior Court in Washington has the jurisdiction to hear it. WASH. CONST. art. IV, § 6. However, the general rule is that once a venue objection is made, and the court finds venue is improper, the court has only two options 1) transfer the petition to a proper venue, or 2) dismiss the petition. If the disqualifying conviction is from another state, the general rule regarding venue does not apply. Any Superior Court in Washington retains jurisdiction to decide the merits of the petition. Arends v. State, No. 103068-1 (Aug. 14, 2025).
(Editor’s Note: The Court agreed with the court of appeals that the petitioner did not have a “vested right,” under former RCW 9.41.040(4)(b), to file the petition in his county of residence. The vested rights doctrine does not apply to a form of procedure such as venue.)
Division I:
Attenuation doctrine – The attenuation doctrine applies in the Article 1, § 7 context when an intervening circumstance brings about a discovery beyond the foreseeable results of the police misconduct. Here, a third-party witness’s voluntary statements to law enforcement were an intervening circumstance going beyond the foreseeable results of the police improperly using CSS technology without a magistrate’s permission to locate the defendant’s phone. Thus, the statements were admissible. State v. Parker, No. 88034-9-I (Aug. 11, 2025).
Blake – A defendant is not entitled to resentencing under Blake if it is clear from the record that the trial court would have imposed the same sentence even without the offender score error. State v. Parker, No. 88034-9-I (Aug. 11, 2025).
Division II:
Blake – A DNA profile in CODIS was not collected “without authority of law,” in violation of Article 1, § 7, just because the sample was collected pursuant to a conviction that was subsequently vacated due to an unconstitutional criminal statute. Blake did not hold RCW 43.43.754, the statute that authorizes the collection and retention of DNA profiles in CODIS, to be unconstitutional. The State’s failure to notify the defendant that his conviction was vacated and his profile could be expunged did not amount to a violation of his procedural due process rights. State v. Munoz-Hernandez, No. 59255-0-II (August 12, 2025) .
Foreign case of interest:
Ineffective assistance – Refusing to present a legally untenable defense does not constitute ineffective assistance of counsel. Criminal defense attorneys have an ethical obligation to refrain from advancing frivolous defenses, and an obligation to disclose to the tribunal any legal authority that is adverse to the client’s position. State v. Baverov, No. A-0274-23 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div., Aug. 11, 2025) .
Division I:
Blake – CrR 7.8 does not authorize courts to vacate charges that were already dismissed upon successful completion of drug court. Nor does CrR 7.8 authorize courts to refund fees that are not LFO’s, such as drug court participation fees. State v. Peterson, No. 85791-6-1 (Aug. 4, 2025).
(Editor’s note: The court assumed, without deciding, other avenues for the same relief may exist via motions brought under Chapter 10.97 RCW to delete or to not disclose nonconviction data, or via motions to refund therapeutic court participation fees based on the holding and policy reasons set out in Blake. “It is conceivable too that either payment of drug court fees or the continued existence of nonconviction data, or both, could satisfy the restraint showing for a matter to be considered as a PRP.”)
9th Circuit:
Notice – The Sixth Amendment does not require “punishment enhancing facts” – facts serving solely to increase the prescribed range of penalties to which a defendant is exposed – to be pled in the charging instrument. The Notice requirement is not limited to the charging document. These facts are not essential elements of the crime. Apprendi and Blakely require those facts to be submitted to a jury, and proved beyond a reasonable doubt, but did not change the notice requirement for states. Handley v. Moore, No. 24-499 (9th Cir. July 29, 2025).
Washington Supreme Court:
Blake – Consequences of the Blake decision are not self-executing. An arrest warrant issued for an offender pursuant to a void conviction is voidable, but was not automatically void upon publication of the Blake decision. State v. Balles, No. 103582-9 (July 31, 2025).
Pretrial conditions – No authority of law authorizes a judge to order the patting down, handcuffing, and detaining a criminal defendant for the purposes of complying with RCW 10.98.050 (administrative booking.) State v. Evans, No. 103136-0 (July 31, 2025).
Standard of review – The standard of review of the sufficiency of the evidence in a bench trial is the same as a jury trial: whether, after viewing all of the evidence, presented in a light most favorable to the State, any rational trier of fact could have found guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. A trial court’s written findings and conclusions do not limit appellate review. State v. Roberts, No. 103546-2 (July 31, 2025).
Offender scoring – A point is properly added to the offender score of a defendant who commits a felony while being supervised by Washington DOC under the Interstate Compact for Adult Offender Supervision, regardless of whether the underlying foreign crime is comparable to a Washington offense. State v. Roberts, No. 103546-2 (July 31, 2025).
Recall – A recall petition will be dismissed if the next general election in which the elected official is up for reelection is less than six months away because the recall sponsors cannot meet the time limit in RCW 29A.56.150(1), and a court can no longer provide effective relief. In the Matter of Recall of Ruelas, No. 103542-0 (Jul. 31, 2025).
Division I:
Community custody conditions – A condition of community custody that the offender “remain within geographic boundaries, as set forth in writing by the CCO” is not unconstitutionally vague. RCW 9.94A.704 limits DOC’s authority to those reasonably related to… “[t]he crime of conviction, the offender’s risk of reoffending, or the safety of the community.” State v. Lundstrom, No. 86537-4-I (July 28, 2025).
Sexual assault protection orders – Courts do not need to determine whether the respondent in a SAPO petition has criminal capacity or is old enough to form the criminal intent necessary to commit the alleged crime. Conduct that would not support criminal liability can still be a basis for obtaining a sexual assault protection order. Jones v. Darragh, No. 86397-5-I (Jul. 28, 2025).
Division II:
Conspiracy – A defendant who gave his sister a gun and persuaded her to shoot him at work so he could file an L&I claim can be held criminally liable for Conspiracy to Commit Assault 2 and Conspiracy to Commit Drive-By Shooting. Although the legislature expressly prohibits victims being liable under an Accessory theory, the same is not true for Conspiracy. State v. Floe, No. 59948-1-II (July 29, 2025)
Blake – Due process does not require the State to refund the $370 that defendant paid toward the $500 drug court participation fee because the fee was not from a conviction, but from a contract entered when simple drug possession was a crime. The Eighth Amendment’s excessive fines clause does not apply because the fee was not punitive and therefore was not a fine. The contract doctrine of “frustration” does not require a refund because the $370 was for the State’s partial performance that occurred before Blake frustrated the contract. “Unjust enrichment” does not require a refund because that theory does not apply when there is a contract. “Mutual mistake” does not apply because Blake did not nullify the contract or render defendant’s agreement unknowing or involuntary. Former RCW 10.01.160(3) and Blazina do not apply because the trial court did not sentence the defendant. Extortion does not apply because the State did not unlawfully threaten the defendant into entering the contract. State v. Ward, No. 58969-9-II (July 29, 2025, unpublished)
Foreign cases of interest:
Nondisclosure orders – The Stored Communications Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2705, requires that a court issuing a search warrant or subpoena make a determination for each warrant or subpoena that disclosure to the user would harm the government’s case. A court cannot issue a blanket nondisclosure Order that applies to all future warrants or subpoenas in an investigation. In Re: Sealed Case, No. 24-5089 (D.C. Cir., July 18, 2025).
Sex offenders – States may require convicted sex offenders to participate in a sex-offender program as a condition of parole without providing any more process than a criminal trial (or a plea) on the underlying offense. McClendon El v. Washington, et al., No. 24-1849 (6th Cir., July 21, 2025).
Second Amendment – A federal statute (18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(4)) prohibiting firearm possession by a person previously involuntarily committed to a mental institution, but now released, is not facially unconstitutional because situations exist where the statute may be applied consistent with the Second Amendment. Release from a mental institution (in West Virginia) is not equivalent to a judicial determination that the person is no longer dangerous. United States v. Gould, No. 24-4192 (4th Cir. July 29, 2025).
Washington Supreme Court:
Crime Victims’ Compensation Fund – A sentencing court cannot reduce the amount of restitution owed to the Crime Victims’ Compensation program. State v. Morgan, No. 102643-9 (January 23, 2025).
Division II:
Blake – A person who requested community service in lieu of legal financial obligations for a conviction now vacated pursuant to State v. Blake is not entitled to reimbursement for the hours spent performing community service. State v. Sindars, No. 58839-1-II (January 22, 2025).
Division III:
Deeds – A recorded Deed of Trust that inadequately describes the property does not encumber the property. The property description in the recorded interest must be clear enough for the court to understand it without extrinsic evidence or testimony. A cover sheet cannot be used to correct an inadequate description. A court may not disregard an incorrect legal description in a deed under a theory of construing it. Errors in a property description cannot be corrected by one party unilaterally striking out words and writing in new words, and recording the corrected version, without clear and convincing evidence that both parties to the deed approved the edits. William & Maria Lawson v. Bankers Insurance Co, et al, No. 40213-4-III (Jan. 21, 2025).
Sufficiency of the evidence – Testimony by the victim that the approximate value of stolen goods was “approximately $1500” is insufficient to establish the value of the goods was over $750, even with photographs of the stolen property and evidence that the value estimate did not include all the stolen property. Testimony regarding value must establish “fair market value” and must include a basis for the opinion. State v. Golyshevsky, No. 58335-6-II (January 22, 2025, unpublished).
Ninth Circuit:
Notice – Placing tickets and a tow notice on the windshield of an illegally parked car provides the car’s owner sufficient notice that the car is about to be towed. However, the owner letting the tickets pile up on the windshield does not provide adequate notice to the city that the owner isn’t checking the windshield of his car for legal process. Grimm v. Portland, No. 23-35235 (9th Cir., January 3, 2025) .
Foreign case of interest:
Second amendment – A state law that effectively bans 18-to-20-year-olds from carrying firearms outside their homes during a state of emergency is not consistent with the Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Madison Lara v. Commissioner PA State Police, No. 21-1832 (3rd Cir., January 13, 2025).