WEEKLY ROUNDUP FOR THE WEEK OF September 1
Washington Supreme Court:
Employment law – In 2022, the legislature amended RCW 49.58.110(1) to require employers with 15 or more employees to disclose salary, wage, and benefits information in all job postings. Violations of this requirement entitles “job applicants” to $100 – $5,000 per violation plus attorneys’ fees. RCW 49.58.110(5)(a). “Job applicant” means a person who applies to a job posting, regardless of their subjective intent. Plaintiffs need not show they are “bona fide” applicants, or that they applied in “good faith,” or that they were qualified for the job, or that they sincerely wanted the job, or that they weren’t simply applying so they could recover the statutory damages. Branson v. Washington Fine Wine & Spirits, LLC, No. 103394-0 (Sep. 4, 2025).
Division I:
Indeterminate Sentence Review Board – The ISRB abused its discretion when it denied the petitioner’s request for release without meaningfully considering whether appropriate release conditions could lower the petitioner’s risk of reoffending to an acceptable level. The ISRB listed possible release conditions, and said they were insufficient, but did not say why they were insufficient, other than relying on the doctor’s conclusion that the petitioner was a Sexually Violent Predator (SVP) and was likely to reoffend regardless of release conditions. The ISRB, the court explained, should not have relied so heavily on the doctor’s evaluation because the evaluation was five years old and the petitioner was entitled to be reevaluated yearly under 71.09 RCW. Additionally, the petitioner disputed that he was a SVP, thus he was entitled to a determination by a fact finder, not just by the doctor. In Re the Personal Restrain of Day, No. 87505-3-I (Sept. 2, 2025).
Restitution – An appellate court’s decision to reverse and remand a restitution order for a hearing on the causal connection between the conviction, and the restitution amount ordered, is not necessarily a “modification” of the trial court’s restitution order. Therefore, RAP 12.8 (which authorizes refunds for overpaid restitution in appropriate circumstances) did not apply. And even if it did, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by denying defendant’s request for reimbursement of restitution. Nelson v. Colorado, 581 U.S. 128, 139 (2017) is inapplicable because the underlying conviction was not overturned. There was no due process violation because the defendant may still bring a civil action against the parties who ultimately received the money he paid and may receive a refund from them if appropriate. State v. Butcher, No. 86575-7-I (Sep. 2, 2025, unpublished).
Hearsay – A detective’s testimony that the defendant’s friend used a racial slur to describe the victim during the friend’s interview with the detective after the defendant killed the victim was not hearsay because the statement was not used to prove the truth of the matter asserted. Rather, the statement was used to prove the friend’s state of mind. However, the statement should have been excluded if the friend’s state of mind was irrelevant. The court did not decide whether the trial court erred by admitting the statement because any error was harmless. State v. Hoffman, No. 85456-9-I Sept. 2, 2025, unpublished).