WEEKLY ROUNDUP FOR THE WEEK OF JULY 21, 2025
Division I:
SSOSA – Invited error doctrine precludes an offender who was granted a SSOSA from appealing the conditions of sentence that were recommended by the offender’s evaluation and that were argued by the offender (and relied upon by the court) as reasons to grant the SSOSA. State v. Smith, No. 86394-1-I (July 21, 2025).
Division II:
Standing – Counties have standing to argue the funding system for indigent defense violates defendants’ right to counsel and equal protection. Counties are within the “zone of interest” of the funding system that they are challenging because the funding system is intended to help counties meet their constitutional requirement to provide indigent defense services. The “injury in fact” requirement is met because the counties allege the current funding system directly harms the counties’ ability to meet their constitutional duty to provide indigent defense. But even if the zone of interest or injury in fact requirements was a close call, the court would still find standing because of the public importance of the issue. Washington State Assoc. of Counties v. State, No. 60179-6-II (July 22, 2025).
Division III:
Vacation – Two violations of violating the same domestic violence no-contact Order, separated by five months, are not a “single incident” as defined in the vacation statute, RCW 9.96.060(f)(ii), and cannot be vacated. State v. Marvin, No. 40113-8-III (July 23, 2025).
9th Circuit:
Evidence – Visual identification lies within the province of the factfinder, who may properly compare photographic or video evidence of the culprit’s identity with the defendant’s courtroom appearance. The defendant’s courtroom appearance is not extrinsic evidence, regardless of whether it is somehow formally introduced into the record. United States v. Hassan, No 24-263 (9th Cir., July 22, 2025).