WEEKLY ROUNDUP FOR THE WEEKS of June 16 & 23, 2025
Washington Supreme Court:
Public records act – The “deliberative process exemption” (RCW 42.56.280) applies to initial offers for collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) and does not end until the legislature has funded the CBA. Citizen Action Def. Fund v. Off. of Fin. Mgmt. No. 103379-2 (June 26, 2025).
Employment law – Public employees in Washington State are entitled to paid leave when their military service requires them to be absent from their employment with state or local government even if they are not “scheduled to work” by the employer due to the length of their absence for military service. Barden v. City of Ocean Shores, No. 103121-1 (June 26, 2025).
Division I:
GR 37 – GR 37’s purpose is to prevent the use of peremptory challenges based on racial stereotypes or generalizations, not specific facts. Here, a preemptory challenge was proper for a prospective juror who is a woman of color because she was a witness in the same prosecutor’s recent case who had to be arrested pursuant to a material witness warrant, booked into jail, compelled to testify, and impeached by the State. State v. Mejia, No. 86244-8-I (June 23, 3035, unpublished).
(Editor’s note: This unpublished case has an unusual fact pattern. It is included because such situations may be more common in smaller counties and for the proposition that preemptory challenges are still possible under GR 37.)
Division II:
Vicarious liability – Where an employer concedes that its employee was acting within the scope of their employment during the allegedly negligent act, and that it is vicariously liable for the employee’s negligence, a simultaneous negligent retention claim is superfluous and cannot be brought. Earl v. City of Tacoma, No. 59220-7-II (Jun. 17, 2025).
Foreign cases of interest:
Second amendment – 18 U.S.C. § 922(b)(1), which prohibits the commercial sale of handguns to those under 21, does not violate the second amendment, because those under 21 were “infants” at common law and at the time of the ratification of the constitution, and unable to contract for the purchase of anything other than necessities. McCoy v. ATF, No. 23-2085 (4th Cir. June 18, 2025).
(Editor’s note: There is a brief concurring opinion worth reading.)
Second amendment – 18 U.S.C. § 922(q)(2)(A), which prohibits firearm possession within 1000’ of a school, is not unconstitutional as applied to a man who possessed an AR-15 in a car parked in front (within 40’) of a school. United States v. Allam, 24-40065 (5th Cir. June 16, 2025).
(Editor’s note: The Defendant challenged the statute facially in the District Court, who found it constitutional. This appellate decision only addresses the Defendant’s as-applied challenge.)