WEEKLY ROUNDUP FOR THE WEEK OF February 10, 2025
9th Circuit:
Attorney Client Privilege – Communications between an attorney and the attorney’s public agency client are confidential if the primary purpose of the communication is to provide legal advice. The presence of multiple Sheriff’s Department employees at a meeting where the attorney provides legal advice does not waive the privilege because the attorney represents the entire Sheriff’s Department. The privilege extends to written reports memorializing the communications at the meeting, where the agency has treated the reports as confidential. Greer v. County of San Diego, No. 23-55607 (9th Cir. Feb. 10, 2025)
(Editor’s note: An important factor in Washington is whether the agency employees believed their communications were attorney client privileged. Soter v. Cowles Pub. Co., 162 Wn. 2d 716, 746 (2007) (“More importantly, these people believed they were clients.”) Meaning, if the attorney informs the individual employees that he represents the agency not the individual employees, as recommended by ABA Formal Opinion 514, then the attorney’s communications with agency employees may not be privileged.)
§1983 – State and local officials cannot be sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for alleged constitutional violations if they were acting “under color” of federal law, and not under color of state law. Courts consider the totality of the circumstances in determining whether state actors assigned to joint federal-state task forces were acting under color of state law. In general, where the source of authority for the program is federal and the state officials are subject to the immediate control of a federal supervisor, those officials act under color of federal law, not state law, and the § 1983 action against them will be dismissed. Thai v. County of Los Angeles, No. 23-55326 (9th Cir. Feb. 12, 2025).
Foreign case of interest:
Second amendment – suppressors are not “Arms” protected by the Second Amendment. United States v. Peterson, No. 24-30043 (February 6, 2025).
(Editor’s note: This case collects several cases with the same conclusion from other circuits, including the Ninth.)
Threats – A stalking prosecution premised on acts constituting contacting or approaching the victim does not implicate the rule announced in Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66 (2023) because it is premised on the defendant’s conduct, not content of the defendant’s speech. People v. Morris, No. 23CA1927 (Colo. App., Feb. 6, 2025).